Add thelocalreport.in As A Trusted Source
Okay guys, this is getting really weird…
I tried to ignore it but I couldn’t. This is very strange.
I just ask that you don’t make any decisions on this until I reach the end and then you can draw whatever conclusions you want.
You know, sometimes they say give someone enough rope and they’ll hang on to it, and I wonder if that’s what we’re starting to see with Erica Kirk’s frequent media appearances?
Because people are beginning to notice that what she says doesn’t match reality.
So let’s start here with Erica Kirk saying that she “never dated” when she lived in New York. I don’t care whether he did it or not, I’m just reporting on what he claimed.
The next logical question might be, well, when did Erica live in New York?
Glad you asked:
Erica Kirk (née Frantzway): Residence and career timeline
Initial New York residency (2012–2017)
Erica Kirk lived new york city Evidence pointing to habitation there was found in the vicinity, mainly during the late 2010s. 2012-2013 at least until then 2021When she married and moved her primary life to Arizona with her husband Charlie Kirk.
After winning Miss Arizona USA and competing in Miss USA in late 2011 2012 (Held in Las Vegas, but included preparations and events in NYC, where she was photographed with other contestants in May 2012), she pursued modeling, acting, and entertainment. Sources describe his spending significant time in New York (and abroad, for example, China) for these careers, including purchasing a one-way ticket to NYC “several years ago” relative to the early 2020 profile.
Career and personal milestones (2018–2021)
By 2018She was apparently living in Manhattan (or Brooklyn according to some records), as multiple reports suggest she lived there when she met Charlie Kirk in NYC that year and began dating him (first date in September 2018).
Transition to Arizona (2021–present)
He continued professional ties to New York in the 2020s (for example, listed as working there until 2025 in some profiles), but after marrying in May 2021 and having children (2022 and 2024), the couple lived primarily in Arizona (Scottsdale/Phoenix area).
So now watch this clip where she says she didn’t date at all while she lived in New York, despite the fact that she was literally on a dating reality TV show – and I’m going to show you below that she very clearly was dating, and the man she was dating has now taken Charlie Kirk’s place on the TPUSA circuit.
Yes true.
start here:
‼️🇺🇸: Erica Kirk on ‘Town Hall’ Said She “Never Dated in New York” for Years Despite Appearing on “Summer House,” a dating reality TV show at New York Week in 2018, before meeting Charlie.
She even goes so far as to criticize her then roommate for dating… https://t.co/n7B6tPw093 pic.twitter.com/RTaVI52ojn
– Diligent Denison 🇺🇸 (@DiligentDenizen) 16 December 2025
Here she is on the dating show:
‼️🇺🇸: Erica Kirk (Frantzway) appeared in 2 episodes of “Summer House” season 3 episodes 11 and 12.
They were filmed in The Hamptons in August of 2018, a few weeks later she met Charlie Kirk and had an “interview”, and it eventually turned into a date.
She lived in NYC for 4 years. pic.twitter.com/ytK9sv9gWe
– Diligent Denison 🇺🇸 (@DiligentDenizen) 28 September 2025
Okay, so besides actually being on a dating reality TV show — let’s put that aside and say it doesn’t count — it sure looks like she was definitely dating a guy named Cabot Phillips:
‼️🇺🇸: THIS IS IT: Erica Frantzway Kirk was dating Cabot Phillips right before she met Charlie Kirk, despite claiming to be single.
The Wayback Machine shows that Cabot and Erica scoured their Twitter profiles for evidence.
It appears Charlie Kirk didn’t know because… https://t.co/fb1p6MCEx7 pic.twitter.com/28b3l3Nngp
– Diligent Denison 🇺🇸 (@DiligentDenizen) 16 December 2025
Free country again! Date whoever you want!
But the problem comes when you told us that you have never dated in the last 5 years of living in New York.
The other problem is that those tweets have now been removed and sanitized from the internet. Almost as if Erica and/or Cabot didn’t want anyone to see them?
But there’s something called The Wayback Machine and it stores tweets right here:
https://web.archive.org/web/20170919180658/https://twitter.com/cabot_phillips
I confirmed myself and took this screenshot:
![]()
But not only this.
Let’s keep going.
As you can see from that post, the date at the top right of the Wayback Machine tells you that it was posted on September 19, 2017.
Now look at this post from Charlie Kirk seven days later, on September 24, 2017, in which he said he had defeated Cabot Phillips in a one-on-one basketball game:
![]()
I mean, come on guys, what are the chances?
And now the kicker…
This guy who Erica dated before Charlie (and then claimed she didn’t) is now taking Charlie’s place on the TPUSA speaking circuit and is featured in “How to Lead Like Charlie”:
Erica Kirk’s ex-boyfriend is now filling in for Charlie, because that’s not weird at all! pic.twitter.com/8CQQlNrOZd
– Knoxie (@KnoxieLuv) 16 December 2025
![]()
Erica claims that she met Charlie Kirk by chance while on a trip to Israel and he gave her a job interview and they went on a date.
What a lovely story.
Unless it’s real.
At this point, I’m finding it really hard to believe that Erica first met Charlie by chance during a trip to Israel, meanwhile she was literally dating the guy Charlie was playing with just seven days later in 2017.
And now the man has literally taken Charlie’s place on the stage.
Sorry guys, but something stinks to high heaven here!
I want to like Erica. I want to trust Erica. I want to believe that she had her Cinderella story with Charlie and now she’s just a grieving widow, but nothing I’m seeing so far is telling me that any of it is true. Like almost none of it.
And worst of all, as brilliant as he was, it appears as if Charlie was blind to it all, and lived in blissful ignorance.
Maybe it was better that way.
Ugh.
Your thoughts?
Do you think any of this is normal?
Can you really believe at this point that this is all just one big random coincidence?