Add thelocalreport.in As A Trusted Source
IIn 2020, I put £100 into stock market For the first time. Not £1,000. Not £10,000. One hundred pounds. Money I was willing to lose. money what i thought investment Really felt that way.
That £100 changed everything. Not because of the returns, but because it broke the barrier. I learned that investing doesn’t have to be a complicated game for rich people. it was a way of building Property Slowly, steadily, over time. And once I started I kept going.
Now, four years later, Rachel Reeves has announced that from April 2027, Cash ISA allowance to drop from £20,000 to £12,000,
It aims to inspire people to invest at least £8,000 in stocks and shares isaTo get Britain to invest again.
I understand the mission. I agree with the mission. Certainly more people should invest. But This plan won’t work,
numbers that matter
HMRC’s latest annual savings figures make one thing crystal clear: most people are nowhere near the new £12,000 Cash ISA limit. The most common annual ISA contribution is just £1 to £2,499, made by 41.9 per cent of savers.
The average annual ISA subscription is around £6,900. Only 22.7 per cent of people are able to max out the full £20,000—and higher earners are over-represented in this group. Among those earning more than £100,000, the maximum is between 40 per cent and 60 per cent.
So the new limit affects a small, wealthy minority—not the average saver. And when these high earners lose their tax-exempt status, they will no longer be able to become stock market investors. They’ll simply transfer the extra cash to normal taxable accounts — and pay more taxes to do so.
Basic rate taxpayers will now pay 22 per cent on interest on their £1,000 allowance. Higher rate taxpayers over £500 will pay 42 per cent. Instead of creating more investors, this policy only creates more taxable savers.
Get free fractional shares worth up to £100.
Capital at risk.
terms and Conditions apply.
Advertisement
Get free fractional shares worth up to £100.
Capital at risk.
terms and Conditions apply.
Advertisement
why won’t this work
Reeves said in his budget speech: “The UK has the lowest level of retail investment in the G7, and that’s not just bad for businesses, which need that investment to grow. It’s also bad for savers.”
He is right. But the problem isn’t that Cash ISAs are too generous. The problem is warnings. Open any investment app and you’ll get messages like: “Capital at risk.” “You may get back less than you invested.” “Past performance does not guarantee future results.”
Sometimes it feels like there are more warnings than there are gambling sites.
These warnings are necessary. They are mandatory. but they are Horrible If you have never invested before. They make you feel like you’re about to risk your life savings.
Meanwhile, Cash ISAs have no caveats. No red banner. No reminder that inflation quietly destroys 2-3 percent of your savings every year. You cannot force someone to come to the stock market by making cash less attractive.
You have to show them why it is worth the investment.
What exactly got me to invest
That £100 I mentioned? Here’s why it worked: I was lucky. I went in search of information. I found manufacturers and platforms that explained investing simply.
Most people never get that far. Many don’t even know where to start.
I didn’t invest because the government restricted my savings options…education gave me a start. Not punishment.
I didn’t invest because the government had restricted my savings options. I invested because someone helped me understand it. Because I started small.
Because once I got into the game the fear went away. Education started me. Not punishment.
what will actually work
If the goal is to get investment to Britain, what should happen instead:
- education campaignshow people How does compound growth work?explain risk vs volatilityMake investment feel understandable, not dangerousIf stocks and shares isa There needs to be a wall of warnings, Cash ISA should at least mention this Inflation drains your money every year, encourage, not punishGive people a reason to get started, Perhaps a government bonus for 18-30 year olds who open their first Stocks and Shares ISA and contribute up to £1,000, Like a simplified Lifetime ISA, but purely for investing, The hardest part is getting started, A little encouragement helps people overcome obstacles, Once they overcome this, they keep moving forward, Make it about starting, not maxing outThe goal should not be “everyone should invest £8,000,” It should be “Everyone should try to invest in something,” Once you put in £100 or £500, you’ll learn more in a month than in a year of studying, You are seeing the benefits, You are seeing a loss, You stop being afraid, This is when behavior changes,
what will actually happen
There is approximately £300 billion held in Cash ISAs across the UK. This policy will not suddenly move that money into the stock market. This will easily redirect future savings into taxable accounts.
Those who have already invested will continue to invest. Those who prefer cash will transfer the extra amount to taxable accounts – and pay more taxes for doing so.
Those over 65 have been exempted from the change, which shows the government understands the time frame matters. But not all people under 65 are the same.
A 30-year-old who is building an emergency fund and a 50-year-old who is preparing for retirement have completely different needs. Yet both are being given the same ultimatum: invest or pay taxes. And when many people choose to pay taxes instead, the government will claim that people don’t want to invest. But this is not necessarily true. They just don’t want to be forced.
challenge
If you save in a cash ISA, check how much you actually contribute each year.
Most people aren’t even close to £12,000, so nothing changes for them. If your income is more than £12,000, you have until April 2027 to plan.
And that plan could be to start investing. But do it because you want to, not because Rachel Reeves made cashing in a little less attractive.
Start from £100. or £500. Whatever risks you are willing to take while learning. Feel what it’s like. Get used to swings. Then keep going. Because investing works when you understand it. When you select it. When you’re ready for it. Not when you’re pushed into it.
If there’s one thing I’ve learned: you can force people to pay more taxes. You cannot force them to become investors.
When investing, your capital is at risk and you may get back less than you invested. Past performance does not guarantee future results.